ecaminc.com

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home Blog: Back From Red General Blog Indecision: The Graveyard Of Good Intentions
E-mail Print PDF
RSS

Picture representing indecisionIndecision: The Graveyard Of Good Intentions

"People say I am indecisive, but I am not so sure about that." I have seen this quote attributed to a former US President, but I doubt it. First, it is too intelligent a comment for him and, second, he is far from indecisive. The liberal pundits trying to attribute that quote to him confuse indecision with defective decision making. You can figure out who the President is on your own; however, it is irrelevant. This article is about leadership not politics. Organizations confronted with a decision-challenged individual in a leadership role, is adrift in the sea of serendipity. They bobble around having no direction.

The Problem With Indecision

Indecision is worse than a bad decision. With direction, even poor direction, the individuals affected can properly plan its execution, implement mitigations for its problems, and define contingencies when its plans start to falter. Rivals to the direction do the same, obviously, in an opposing manner. The result is a set of critical plans covering nearly all aspects of a decision—regardless of the decision's quality. Indecision denies the framework for proper planning. It leaves everyone unprepared to suffer consequences of fate, removing the ability to influence the result to fit the stakeholder's requirements.

Fear of the Poor Decision

The source of paralyzed pronouncements is the fright of a poor decision. Affected individuals, with the best of intentions, hide their fear behind two general behavioral traits—ignorance and over analysis.

With blissful ignorance, also known as unrealistically optimism, the hope is that all will work out based on the misguided belief that there really are no problems. In this situation, the realist is considered negative, a pessimist, disruptive to the team, and is usually banished from the organization. In the end, this is the best outcome for the realist. Otherwise, they are condemned to eternal frustration and, if their prognostications become reality, they wear the blame for the self-fulfilling their prophecy. No one wins.

The opposing trait is deferring the decision in anticipation that new specks of data will create an irrefutable edict. Analyze, collect data, analyze more, and search for more data. The typical scenario brings in consultant after consultant to assess the problem and leaders wait for the answer they want to hear. Meanwhile, time ticks away and fate takes its toll.

Decision Do Not Preclude Change

Poor leaders do not make bad decisions; poor leaders refuse to admit weaknesses in their decisions thereby failing to correct the flaws. By acknowledging that a decision has faults, leaders create an environment that fosters critical thinking. This is an environment that reinforces every aspect of success: critical thinking prior to the decision, wide spread support of the decision, and development of mitigation plans when weaknesses are found in the decision. Most importantly, when (not if) flaws are found in the decision, it provides the platform for non-accusatory change. The result is that lessons are learned in an atmosphere devoid of blame. Everyone wins.

Affecting Change

Understanding the reasons for the indecision is fundamental in affecting change. Attempting to push the eternal optimist to accept reality or convince the consternated analyst that the data in conclusive, is fruitless. You must define alternate route. The only avenue to address the issue is your ability to objectively lead.

It takes a leader to make effective decisions. The person's position or rank is irrelevant. The leader is identified, in part, by their ability to make and be accountable for decisions, to assemble a team to assist in the definition, execution, and continued critical evaluation of the decision.

Delicious Delicious
Add to Technorati Favorites

Accountability, though, is the most critical trait. It instills trust from the team and the stakeholders. It is contagious. Peers and subordinates will step up and model the behavior. In short, accountability subverts a superior's indecision. It imbues leadership below the consternation and drives the organization forward.

Tags: , ,

Previous Blog Next Blog
 

Comments  

 
+1 # Shierl 2011-08-30 06:16
Good description of Washington DC. My solution? 470 brand new faces in 2013.
 
 
0 # Gloria Green 2011-12-03 10:11
While indecision provides blissful ignorance, it is the source of the fires that continually need to be put out. When the decision is not made on a timely basis, the project team has to scramble to meet an unrealistic deadline.
 

Currently comment rights have been restricted to registered users only. Please try registering and logging on.


Who's Listening To Us...

Fortune/CNN Money logo
 
Forefront's logo
 
Logo Oregonian/OregonLive
 
Enterprising CIO's logo
 
Slashdot's logo
 
The CEO Magazine's logo
 

Read and Hear More...


Visualize Your Future

Change how you do business.

Project Failure Insight:

The following blogs regularly have articles on project failure, recovery and good management practices.
Chris Curran
CIO Dashboard
Michiko Diby
Preventing Project Failure
John Estrella
Dr. John A. Estrella's Blog
Mike Krigsman
IT Project Failures on ZDNet
John F. Moore
Random Thoughts of a Boston-based CTO
Roger Sessions
Simple Architectures for Complex Enterprises

Looking to buy the internationally acclaimed Rescue the Problem Project?

Image of RPP

For a signed and personalized copy in the US visit the book's website.

Not in the US? Try one of these book stores worldwide

Amazon logo
Book or Kindle
Flag of the United States
United States

Flag of Canada
Canada

Flag of the United Kingdom Flag of Ireland
United Kingdom

Flag of Germany
Deutschland

Flag of France
France

Flag of Italy
Italia

Flag of the PRC
中國
Flag of Japan
日本の
Barnes and Noble Logo
Book or Nook
Sony Reader Store logo
Sony Reader
Worldwide: Many other
book sellers worldwide.

Suggested Books

Many of these books have reviews in the "Books to Read" section of this site.

Critical Chain
by Eliyahu Goldratt

Related Items