Back From Red Blog Banner
Sunday, 06 December 2009 00:00

Blame The Customer

Rate this item
(0 votes)

It is amazing how people on failing projects neglect to look at their own issues prior to blaming someone else. Yes, blame is easy and on red projects since no wants to be the source of the issues. The truth is, everyone is at blame, so before bringing in an auditor or recovery manager, tidy up your house first.

One very memorable project illustrates this point. A company was building a thick client sales application using internal IT resources. They had a pipeline of projects to enhance the application, each taking between twelve to fourteen months.

A representative from the PMO called me telling a tale of woe about the latest delivery. It was a miserable failure. The product had been released with a huge number of bugs. The product was deployed over the internet and by default automatically updated sales personnel's computers. With the failure, almost all sales staff's tools were disabled. To make matters worse, the primary failure was caused by the remote update program. It broke itself during the installation making it very difficult to download a fix. The result was a large portion of the sales force was unable to configure products and create bids. No one in the company was happy.

Day One

On the first day at the facility, there were a number of IT managers that set me straight on just where the issues were. It was clearly the customer being too pushy and a project team that could not handle their requests. There was plenty of work to do on the project since a follow-on "fix project" had been initiated to fix the failed deployment. This was affecting the next in the series of projects so it, too, was red. IT's management was emphatic the problem was the business unit being out of control making unreasonable demands. The project team, though, had a different opinion and, along with being demoralized from the failed delivery, was frustrated with their management. The contradiction necessitated an early visit to the accused unreasonable customer. The rest of the day was spent five miles down the road, in the manufacturing facility, talking to them.

The Rules When Auditing Projects
  • Remain objective
  • Interview the people and listen to what they say, but do not take it as fact
  • Listen to your team, they have the answers
  • Get lots of data, it will be your friend
  • Although this case study shows a one sided failure, the customer is not always right

The customer voiced a significant set of issues, including their opinion that I would be unable to help the situation. It was quite clear that the customer was very displeased with the project and did not trust IT's management. The finger pointing between IT and the business unit shutdown communication—it was all just accusations and yelling.

The Plan

That evening I mapped out a schedule to talk to key people. Because of the pressure coming from the customer to fix the failed delivery, I determined it would be best to start there. Calm the customer down and it would buy time to get other issues fixed.

This met with immediate and stern objection from the IT management. They felt the focus should be on the project team; whip them into shape so they would respond to the customer's demands better.

I assured management that attention would turn to the team; however, before addressing any issues on the project, the customer would need to provide a grace period for the audit and analysis. To do that, they needed confidence the problems would be addressed and fixed. First order of business was securing a grace period.

The business's issues were that IT management was unresponsive, had released the product prior to completing proper testing and failed to treat them as a customer. Confirmation of the latter two points was easy. IT management appeared proud of both. Their contention was that the business unit was in the same company, customers bought the company's products. The business unit should focus on selling product, letting IT build the needed applications.

In the next breath, they defended their decision for releasing a buggy product—the product testing was taking too long, it only made sense to release the product. QA was continually sliding their schedule. Had management not told them to do the release "QA would have tested forever." This resulted in the failed delivery. Management refused to acknowledge any culpability in the current mess; it was all QA's fault.

Although the customer claimed they had made numerous complaints about the project, there was no documentation of it. The previous project management had not kept any action items list. It turns out that the prior project management consulting team running the failed project had a separate agenda—to show the business unit that IT was unable to support the product and that it should be outsourced to their company.

I assured the customer that issues would be resolved, even though many of the issues appeared to be with IT management. Customer would need to have patience. Honesty in identifying sources of issues and constant communication convinced them to grant the time.

The Findings

Two weeks later, audit findings were presented to the steering committee. They stated the core issues were:

  1. Animosity between IT management and the business unit was unbearable. This would need to be the primary focus.
  2. The IT test environments were inadequate. They were neither capable of properly reflecting the end users' environment nor executing acceptance test scripts in a timely manner.
  3. Certain people on the IT project team were hostile and uncooperative. They were admittedly unwilling to assist in the project recovery. They would be replaced.
  4. IT management did not understand the need for a product maintenance phase, instead using yearly project releases to address bugs in the product. Bug fix releases would be required.

Nothing in these findings pointed to an unreasonable customer. Even when resolving the communications issue, it was IT that had to change the way they were addressing the business unit—the customer. Later in the project there were places where the customer had to accept blame, these initial big issues, though, all lay in IT's court. As said at the onset "before bringing in an auditor or recovery manager, tidy up your house first"

Remember Jerry?

Remember back a few weeks ago, the article on projects needing value? Well, the Cowboys' owner Jerry Jones exhibited these same traits. As opposed to the height of the world-record video screen, it was the punter who was the problem:

If you look at how you punt the football, unless you're trying to hit the scoreboard, you punt the ball to get downfield. You certainly want to get some hangtime, but you punt the ball to get downfield, and you sure don't punt the ball down the middle. You punt it off to the side.1

Somewhere in the back office, though, there was someone that was a little more reasonable who moved the manufacturer's advertisement from below the screen to above it in order to give punters more room.

 

More in this category:
Next Post Previous post
Read 4425 times
Login to post comments

Related items

  • Alignment: Using the Balanced Scorecard to Create Corporate Synergies
    Alignment: Using the Balanced Scorecard to Create Corporate Synergies

    Add To Cart

    Author:Robert S. Kaplan, David P. Norton
    Publisher: Harvard Business Review Press
    Released: April 2006
    Type: Hardcover
    Pages: 320
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Projects build capabilities to met corporate goals. If you are a CEO, you need to make sure your employees and vendors know what those goals are and how they fit in to the plan. If you are a project manager, you need to know the bounds of you project. If you are anywhere in-between, you need to understand how all the pieces fit together and keep it all aligned.

    Most organizations consist of multiple business and support units, each populated by highly trained, experienced executives. But often the efforts of individual units are not coordinated, resulting in conflicts, lost opportunities, and diminished performance.

    Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton argue that the responsibility for this critical alignment lies with corporate headquarters. In this book, the authors apply their revolutionary Balanced Scorecard management system to corporate-level strategy, revealing how highly successful enterprises achieve powerful synergies by explicitly defining corporate headquarters ’ role in setting, coordinating, and overseeing organizational strategy.

    Based on extensive field research in organizations worldwide, Alignment shows how companies can build an enterprise-level Strategy Map and Balanced Scorecard that clearly articulate the “enterprise value proposition ”: how the enterprise creates value above that achieved by individual business units operating alone. The book provides case studies, actionable frameworks, and sample scorecards that show how to align business and support units, boards of directors, and external partners with the corporate strategy and create a governance process that will ensure that alignment is sustained.

    The next breakthrough in strategy execution from the field ’s premier thinkers, Alignment shows how today ’s companies can unlock unrealized value from enterprise synergies.

    Buy it now!

  • ADKAR: A Model for Change in Business, Government and our Community
    ADKAR: A Model for Change in Business, Government and our Community

    Add To Cart

    Author: Jeffrey M. Hiatt
    Publisher: Prosci Learning Center Publications
    Released: August 2006
    Type: Softcover
    Pages: 146
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Tired of hearing about change and how your project is implementing it, but have no idea how to make it happen? ADKAR is the gold standard process to follow to help make that happen. This, and a little leadership, will get you ahead of the pack.

    Why do some changes fail while others succeed?

    How can you make sense of the many tools and approaches for managing change?

    How can you lead change successfully, both in your personal life and professional career?

    After more than 14 years of research with corporate change, the ADKAR model has emerged as a holistic approach that brings together the collection of change management work into a simple, results oriented model. This model ties together all aspects of change management including readiness assessments, sponsorship, communications, coaching, training and resistance management. All of these activities are placed into a framework that is oriented on the required phases for realizing change with individuals and the organization

    The ADKAR perspective can help you develop a "new lens" through which to observe and influence change. You may be working for change in your public school system or in a small city council. You may be sponsoring change in your department at work. You may be observing large changes that are being attempted at the highest levels of government or you may be leading an enterprise-wide change initiative. The perspective enabled by the ADKAR model allows you to view change in a new way. You can begin to see the barrier points and understand the levers that can move your changes forward. ADKAR allows you to understand why some changes succeed while others fail. Most importantly, ADKAR can help your changes be a success. Based on research with more than 1100 companies from 59 countries, ADKAR is a simple and holistic way to manage change.

    Buy it now!

  • The Next Evolution - Enhancing and Unifying Project and Change Management: The Emergence One Method for Total Project Success
    The Next Evolution - Enhancing and Unifying Project and Change Management: The Emergence One Method for Total Project Success

    Add To Cart

    Author:Thomas Luke Jarocki
    Publisher: Brown & Williams Publishing
    Released: June 2011
    Type: Hardcover
    Pages: 326
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Still confused on how projects and change management fit together? If so, read this book. It gives a great history of both and outlines a process that may work for your company. If nothing else, the process described will help you understand how your company can fold the two disciplines together. The only detractor is the author's contniual reference to "his" methodology. However, this does give you a good example of its implementation.

    Just about every project professional agrees that "success" today is not just about being "on time, within budget, and according to scope" but one in which there is successful organizational change and the broad organizational adoption of project outputs and deliverables. However, because the project management and organizational/behavioral change management disciplines are often practiced as separate entities, the road to success often becomes divided, leading to poor outcomes for both the project manager and stakeholders throughout the organization.

    The Next Evolution, details a better way. By integrating, enhancing, and unifying the latest, most effective practices from both the project management and change management fields, project professionals will no longer have to rely on the ineffective practice of employing two separate methodologies to address the two most critical elements of project success: task execution and successful stakeholder/change management (also known as the "people side").

    It offers real-world insights and practical solutions for:

    • Business leaders trying to understand how best to achieve true business value, stakeholder satisfaction, and complete organizational adoption of their initiative.
    • Project managers looking to enhance the quality of project execution by augmenting their practices with tangible, more effective organizational change/stakeholder management technique.
    • Change management professionals looking for updated approaches to facilitating change or need a clearer path on how best to integrate and leverage opportunities within a master project plan.
    • Project professionals who need a detailed, comprehensive project life cycle methodology to deftly plan and execute a variety of initiatives.

    Overview:

    "Projects are the vehicles of change." As such, successful initiatives require deft execution (project management) and the proactive mitigation of human, political, and organizational change issues (change management).

    Despite the fact that these two disciplines are critical to the overall success of any organizational initiative, these two fields are often practiced as separate disciplines. Each applies its own set of tools, techniques, and methodologies (and sometimes separate project teams as well!) to the same initiative. This inadvertently creates a schizophrenic approach to project success where critical interdependencies and joint opportunities are never fully realized. The results are unnecessary project expenses and delays, increased stakeholder frustration, and low rates of organizational adoption and business value realization.

    "The Next Evolution - Enhancing and Unifying Project and Change Management" bridges the gap between project management and the practice of organizational/behavioral change management. Accompanying the book is "The Emergence One Method for Total Project Success"; a detailed, step-by-step methodology that integrates and enhances the most effective perspectives, approaches, and techniques of the project management and change management disciplines into one sequential set of activities.

    The book is divided in two parts. Part One - "The Next Evolution" discusses how most project and change management methodologies are hampered by outdated assumptions, legacy inherited deficiencies, and narrow perceptions regarding scope. It also details why well-meaning attempts at integrating these two disciplines quickly become disjointed and frustratingly ineffective. It concludes by explaining why a unifying methodology is required if total project success is to be achieved. In Part Two, "The Emergence One Method for Total Project Success", the complete, step-by-step, Emergence One project life cycle methodology is presented. Each chapter details the goals, objectives, key stakeholder management needs, and activities required to successfully complete each phase of the project life cycle, along with all the real-world insights and caveats necessary to execute with acumen.

    Buy it now!

  • The Strategy-Focused Organization: How Balanced Scorecard Companies Thrive in the New Business Environment
    The Strategy-Focused Organization: How Balanced Scorecard Companies Thrive in the New Business Environment

    Add To Cart

    Author:Robert S. Kaplan, David P. Norton
    Publisher: Harvard Business Review Press
    Released: September 2000
    Type: Hardcover
    Pages: 416
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Projects build capabilities to met corporate goals. If you are a CEO, you need to make sure your employees and vendors know what those goals are and how they fit in to the plan. If you are a project manager, you need to know the bounds of you project. If you are anywhere in between, you need to understand how all the pieces fit together and keep it all aligned.

    Most organizations consist of multiple business and support units, each populated by highly trained, experienced executives. But often the efforts of individual units are not coordinated, resulting in conflicts, lost opportunities, and diminished performance.

    The creators of the revolutionary performance management tool called the Balanced Scorecard introduce a new approach that makes strategy a continuous process owned not just by top management, but by everyone. In The Strategy-Focused Organization, Robert Kaplan and David Norton share the results of ten years of learning and research into more than 200 companies that have implemented the Balanced Scorecard. Drawing from more than twenty in-depth case studies--including Mobil, CIGNA, and AT&T Canada--Kaplan and Norton illustrate how Balanced Scorecard adopters have taken their groundbreaking tool to the next level. These organizations have used the scorecard to create an entirely new performance management framework that puts strategy at the center of key management processes and systems.

    Kaplan and Norton articulate the five key principles required for building strategy-focused organizations: 1) translate the strategy into operational terms, 2) align the organization to the strategy, 3) make strategy everyone's everyday job, 4) make strategy a continual process, and 5) mobilize change through strong, effective leadership. The authors provide a detailed account of how a range of organizations in the private, public, and nonprofit sectors have deployed these principles to achieve breakthrough, sustainable performance improvements.

    Buy it now!

  • Effective Project Management: Traditional, Agile, Extreme
    Effective Project Management: Traditional, Agile, Extreme

    Add To Cart

    Author:Robert K. Wysocki
    Publisher: Wiley
    Released: December 2013
    Type: Softcover
    Pages: 768
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Another great book by Mr. Wysocki, a personal friend. This books continues to meet Bob's standard of well written project management reference and text books.

    The popular guide to the project management body of knowledge, now fully updated.

    Now in its seventh edition, this comprehensive guide to project management has long been considered the standard for both professionals and academics. With more than 32,000 copies sold in the last three editions, it has now been fully updated to cover the new PMBOK 5. Well-known expert Robert Wysocki has added more than 100 pages of new content based on instructor feedback, enhancing the coverage of best-of-breed methods and tools for ensuring project management success.

    With enriched case studies, accompanying exercises and solutions on the companion website, and PowerPoint slides for all figures and tables, the book is ideal for instructors and students as well as active project managers.

    • Serves as a comprehensive guide to project management for both educators and project management professionals
    • Completely updated to cover the new PMBOK 5
    • Examines traditional, agile, and extreme project management techniques; the Enterprise Project Management Model; and Kanban and Scrumban methodologies
    • Includes a companion website with exercises and solutions and well as PowerPoint slides for all the figures and tables used
    • Written by well-known project management expert Robert Wysocki

    Effective Project Management, Seventh Edition remains the comprehensive resource for project management practitioners, instructors, and students.

    Buy it now!

Rescue The Problem Project

Internationally acclaimed

Image of RPP

For a signed and personalized copy in the US visit the our eCommerce website.

Amazon logo
Flag of the United States Buy it in Canada Flag of the United Kingdom
Flag of Ireland Flag of Germany Flag of France
Flag of Italy Flag of the PRC
Flag of Japan
Book sellers worldwide.

Upcoming Events