Back From Red Blog Banner
Monday, 05 July 2010 00:00

The CIO's Role in Project Failure

Rate this item
(0 votes)

CIO nameplate: Who should the CIO report to?

A couple months ago I asked the question, "Who should the CIO report to?" on the LinkedIn's CIO Magazine Forum. Surprisingly, over 100 people responded, so many that the group's moderator moved the discussion to the jobs section. Maybe they were tired of the attention this old, beat-up subject was getting. I surely did not think responses would be quite as passionate as they were. However, my interest lay in another area, not in the answers to the direct question, rather the reasoning behind them.

The Question Behind the Question

To insure getting the desired detail, I framed the query further. In the months prior to posting, I had participated in a roundtable discussion with a number of CIOs of $500M+ companies. This topic came up and a few felt adamant that the CIO should report to the CEO. However, as the discussion evolved, most softened their stance. In the end, there were two general groups of thought, both relatively close in concept:

  1. The CIO needs to be a respected peer of others reporting to the CEO, regardless of the actual reporting structure for the CIO.
  2. The reporting structure needs to be set up based on the technical prowess of the CEO. However, there was a wide diversity of reasons—technophobic CEOs, older risk-averse companies, and corporate cultures opposed to having a non-core competency reporting to the CEO.

The responses to the CIO group posting were about the same—primarily that CIOs should report to the CEO, the next most popular choice was the CFO, and a smattering of COOs and CTOs. Finally, a few folks who refered to who the person was and how well they understood the business. Feel free to join the group review the responses.

It Depends on the CIO

The latter group interested me—it depends on the CIO. The majority that said CIOs should report to the CEO seemed to feel this would give the CIO the credibility to do the job. This is problematic. If you lack the leadership skills, IT competency, or business knowledge to earn respect of the C-level peers, how will reporting structure change that? Rightfully so, if the CIO does not deliver value to the business, he or she will be fired. The only way to deliver value is to understand the business. Not IT, the business.

On the other hand, if you have that knowledge and the CEO's direct reports still fail to recognize you, there is a problem. Reporting to the CEO will not fix that; the cultural problem needs fixing first.

Dilbert's Boss' Visionary Leadership, Dilbert © April 17, 2004, United Feature Syndicate, Inc.

Failing Projects

Now the other angle, the view inside IT. In generalities, IT budgets allocate two-thirds to keep the lights on and one-third to deliver business initiatives. Understanding the value of Forrester's MOOSE (Maintain and Operate the Organization, Systems, and Equipment) is simple—keep everything running all the time. There is only a minimal requirement to understand the inner workings of the business. Analogous to the power company, you need to know the amount of power to supply and little about how it is used.

The other third, initiatives, is quite different. Building or implementing new systems requires business process knowledge, comprehension of business goals, and the variables that affect them. It requires embedding knowledge of multiple processes into a system that can be easily modified in concert with ever changing business environment. This requires IT to understand how the business runs, rather than how many neat features are in a new application.

Lose site of the business and IT managers start making stupid decisions. People second guess management, architects begin thinking the goal is delivering technology, and project managers cannot differentiate between critical scope and nice-to-haves. The Garage SyndromeTM reigns, projects start to fail, moral diminishes and the organization spirals downward. The business loses trust in IT's ability to help streamline its operations.

Want to read more?

Strategy, alignment, communication of goals is not easy. Our Vision To Value white paper talks about focusing your team on the key strategic corporate goals and ensuring everyone in your organization knows the direction.

The CIO's Role

The solution is the CIO. If the CIO understands the business' issues and demands his or her direct reports do the same, the organization's attitude, culture, and drive will change to deliver solutions with a business focus. Everything, including projects, runs better since the focus is away from implementing an application and centered on solutions for the business. This top-down attitude engages everyone in the project's chain of command to understand what is critical to quality.

The reporting structure of the CIO is irrelevant. It is the CIO's complete and thorough understanding of the business that makes the CIO and the IT organization relevant.

More in this category:
Next Post Previous post
Read 5279 times
Login to post comments

Related items

  • Switch: How to Change Things When Change Is Hard  
    Switch: How to Change Things When Change Is Hard

    Add To Cart

    Author:Chip Heath
    Publisher: Crown Business
    Released: February 2010
    Type: Hardcover
    Pages: 320
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Projects drive change and you need to get people to switch to that change to make your project successful. Switch is a great book on how to help make that happen.

    Why is it so hard to make lasting changes in our companies, in our communities, and in our own lives?

    The primary obstacle is a conflict that ’s built into our brains, say Chip and Dan Heath, authors of the critically acclaimed bestseller Made to Stick. Psychologists have discovered that our minds are ruled by two different systems —the rational mind and the emotional mind —that compete for control. The rational mind wants a great beach body; the emotional mind wants that Oreo cookie. The rational mind wants to change something at work; the emotional mind loves the comfort of the existing routine. This tension can doom a change effort —but if it is overcome, change can come quickly.

    In Switch, the Heaths show how everyday people —employees and managers, parents and nurses —have united both minds and, as a result, achieved dramatic results:

    • The lowly medical interns who managed to defeat an entrenched, decades-old medical practice that was endangering patients.
    • The home-organizing guru who developed a simple technique for overcoming the dread of housekeeping.
    • The manager who transformed a lackadaisical customer-support team into service zealots by removing a standard tool of customer service.

    In a compelling, story-driven narrative, the Heaths bring together decades of counterintuitive research in psychology, sociology, and other fields to shed new light on how we can effect transformative change. Switch shows that successful changes follow a pattern, a pattern you can use to make the changes that matter to you, whether your interest is in changing the world or changing your waistline.

    Buy it now!

  • SPIN Selling
    SPIN Selling

    Add To Cart

    Author:Neil Rackham
    Publisher: McGraw-Hill Education
    Released: May 1988
    Type: Softcover
    Pages: 197
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Every project manager and business analyst should read this book. Ignore the implication of the title, which is just an acronym for a process, and dive in to what the customers real problem is that you are trying to solve. This will change your project deliverable to the most value they have ever received.

    Written by Neil Rackham, former president and founder of Huthwaite corporation, SPIN Selling is essential reading for anyone involved in selling or managing a sales force. Unquestionably the best-documented account of sales success ever collected and the result of the Huthwaite corporation's massive 12-year, $1-million dollar research into effective sales performance, this groundbreaking resource details the revolutionary SPIN (Situation, Problem, Implication, Need-payoff) strategy.

    In SPIN Selling, Rackham, who has advised leading companies such as IBM and Honeywell delivers the first book to specifically examine selling high-value product and services. By following the simple, practical, and easy-to-apply techniques of SPIN, readers will be able to dramatically increase their sales volume from major accounts. Rackham answers key questions such as “What makes success in major sales ” and “Why do techniques like closing work in small sales but fail in larger ones? ”

    You will learn why traditional sales methods which were developed for small consumer sales, just won't work for large sales and why conventional selling methods are doomed to fail in major sales. Packed with real-world examples, illuminating graphics, and informative case studies - and backed by hard research data - SPIN Selling is the million-dollar key to understanding and producing record-breaking high-end sales performance.

    Buy it now!

  • Selling to Big Companies
    Selling to Big Companies

    Add To Cart

    Author:Jill Konrath
    Publisher: Kaplan Publishing
    Released: December 2005
    Type: Softcover
    Pages: 272
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    As a project manager, you are all about selling and persuasion. If you are not good at it, you better learn now. This book focuses on communicating in a way to get people to react to you.

    Setting up meetings with corporate decision makers has never been harder. It's almost impossible to get them to pick up the phone. They never return your calls. And if you do happen to catch them, they blow you off right away.

    It's time to stop making endless cold calls or waiting for the phone to ring. In today's crazy marketplace, new sales strategies are needed to penetrate these big accounts.

    Discover how to:

      Target accounts where you have the highest likelihood of success.
    • Find the names of prospects who can use your offering.
    • Create breakthrough value propositions that capture their attention.
    • Develop an effective, multi-faceted account-entry campaign.
    • Overcome obstacles and objections that derail your sale efforts.
    • Position yourself as an invaluable resource, not a product pusher.
    • Have powerful initial sales meetings that build unstoppable momentum.
    • Differentiate yourself from other sellers.

    Use these sure-fire strategies to crack into big accounts, shrink your sales cycle and close more business. Check out the Account Entry Toolkit for ideas on how to apply this process to your own unique business.

    Buy it now!

  • Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting Out of the Box
    Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting Out of the Box

    Add To Cart

    Author: Arbinger Institute
    Publisher: Berrett-Koehler Publishers
    Released: April 2015
    Type: Softcover
    Pages: 240
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Leadership is an art. As a project manager you need to become a better leader. You will not find that in any single book or class. You need to learn, study and practice. It helps you develop tools to better understand the difficult situations you face daily.

    Since its original publication in 2000, Leadership and Self-Deception has become a word-of-mouth phenomenon. Its sales continue to increase year after year, and the book ’s popularity has gone global, with editions now available in over twenty languages.

    Through a story everyone can relate to about a man facing challenges on the job and in his family, the authors expose the fascinating ways that we can blind ourselves to our true motivations and unwittingly sabotage the effectiveness of our own efforts to achieve success and increase happiness.

    This new edition has been revised throughout to make the story even more compelling. And drawing on the extensive correspondence the authors have received over the years, they have added a section that outlines the many ways that readers have been using Leadership and Self-Deception to improve their lives and workplaces —areas such as team building, conflict resolution, and personal growth and development, to name a few.

    Read this extraordinary book and discover what millions already have learned —how to consistently tap into an innate ability that dramatically improves both your results and your relationships.

    Buy it now!

  • HBR's 10 Must Reads on Change Management
    HBR's 10 Must Reads on Change Management

    Add To Cart

    Author:Harvard Business Review, John P. Kotter, W. Chan Kim, Renee Mauborgne
    Publisher: Harvard Business Review Press
    Released: March 2011
    Type: Softcover
    Pages: 224
    ISBN:978-0201835953

    This book is currently under review, more details will be added when available

    Projects are about change. Project managers need to drive their projects so the change is good for their clients and will stick.

    Most company's change initiatives fail. Yours don't have to.

    If you read nothing else on change management, read these 10 articles (featuring “Leading Change, ” by John P. Kotter). We've combed through hundreds of Harvard Business Review articles and selected the most important ones to help you spearhead change in your organization.

    HBR's 10 Must Reads on Change Management will inspire you to:

    • Lead change through eight critical stages
    • Establish a sense of urgency
    • Overcome addiction to the status quo
    • Mobilize commitment
    • Silence naysayers
    • Minimize the pain of change
    • Concentrate resources
    • Motivate change when business is good

    Buy it now!

Rescue The Problem Project

Internationally acclaimed

Image of RPP

For a signed and personalized copy in the US visit the our eCommerce website.

Amazon logo
Flag of the United States Buy it in Canada Flag of the United Kingdom
Flag of Ireland Flag of Germany Flag of France
Flag of Italy Flag of the PRC
Flag of Japan
Book sellers worldwide.

Upcoming Events