Sunday, 10 April 2011 00:00

Project Acrimony: Project Management and Finance

Rate this item
(0 votes)

Picture of accountant

Few events start a project manager's day off worse than a yellow sticky note on his or her monitor saying, "The finance manager would like to talk to you." An email is equally as bad; however, the note at your desk means that someone actually hunted you down looking to talk about, you guessed it, finances. There must be some problem. Everyone knows the finance folks would never wander into project-land to invite you out for a friendly cup of coffee. You quickly review the project's finances. Everything seems in order. With a sigh, you contemplate whether you should walk over and see her or will a phone call be the least painful option? Yes, painful. Anytime the finance manager calls, there is going to be a lot of new work.

Let Project Managers Manage

The fellows in finance never come bearing gifts. I have yet to have a benevolent bean counter walk into my pint-sized cubicle claiming, "You have an extra $50,000 to complete the project." It is usually the quite the opposite. Mumbling arcane accounting argot, they want expenses cut, more reports, recategorization of costs, or the like. More work, with no offer to help.

To help, apply a trick I learned from rescuing projects, request an accounting resource be assigned to the project. Let this person parse the project, dissect the data, and run reports. Bill his or her time directly to the project making sure everyone is aware of the actual cost. This frees up the project manager's time to... well... manage! I have never seen a project go off track because a project manager did not know its earned value. I have seen failures because the project manager was managing the report and not the people. If the reports are of value to the project (a rarity, in my experience), they can be used to develop corrective actions. However, proactive management rarely relies on reports providing details from four or five weeks ago. By the time enough data available to generate a meaningful report, the problem is out of control. Projects cannot be managed by looking in the rearview mirror.

Meeting the Executive's Need

Capital versus expense, earned-value, and other arcane finance topics often poison the relationship between finance and the project. The primary reason is that there is little or no perceived value to the project. In most cases, there is none; they are for project executives. The finance team can best determine capital costs and earn-value calculations. Project executives need to look at each of these requirements, determine their value, who should be generating them, and streamlining processes to remove waste.

When significant financial reporting is required, the best option is to allocate a financial representative with the appropriate expertise to do that work and bill their time to the project. This allows executives to see the actual cost of these functions and requires that they justify the cost. Furthermore, this frees up the project manager's time to manage people rather than a series of reports. The net result is building a cooperative relationship between the project team and finance.

When the Project Manager is at Fault

There are times when the acrimony is an issue only the project manager can solve. Project managers must maintain objectivity. They are simply managing a conduit to provide a product within a given set of constraints—scope, schedule, and budget. If the project's budget needs to be cut or there are simply insufficient funds to accomplish what the customer wants, the project manager needs to push back on the project sponsor. The sponsor must acquire the appropriate funds or trim scope. The project manager and finance representative should be allies in this cause. Too often, the project manager takes on the role of trying to deliver the same functionality at a reduced cost. This approach, sounds accommodating and cooperative, but results in overextended projects that miss their financial and quality goals. The sponsor or customer needs to cut non-essential scope, supply more funds, or cancel the project.

Project Partners

The answer is making friends with finance. Partnering and having them do the esoteric accounting work for compliance and executive reporting. Remove yourself from the ever-changing world of accounting rules and focus on managing the people. For, just when you think you understand the world of GAAP, SEC, and FASB, your company will adopt IFRS and your world will change once again.

Read 8944 times

Related items

  • Kill The White Knight

    There is a reason we do not teach classes on fixing failing projects. Many a cynic feels that we simply do not want to teach our trade, however, our reason is far nobler—we should be teaching prevention rather trying to create white knights to save the day. It is the same philosophy as building a fence at the cliff's edge rather than an emergency room at its base. Our language is replete with idioms telling us to look past the symptom and address problems at their root cause. 'An ounce of prevention versus a pound of cure' or 'a stitch in time saves nine.' Please, feel free to supply your own in the comments. Unfortunately, most of our businesses loathe this philosophy, waiting to address an issue until it is irrefutably broken.

  • The Executive-Project Manager Gap

    It was such an innocuous question, "Working on an article; what is the biggest problem you see with project governance at orgs? Can you comment?" Can I comment? Really? That is like cheese to a mouse. Where could I start—bureaucracy, draconian process, poor executive sponsorship, disengaged leaders? Plenty of fodder, because they all lead to project failure. I fired off, "Creating an over bureaucratic morass stifling innovation & implementing process instead of cultivating leaders." Then the maelstrom started and it went directly to the gap between the executives and projects managers. Naomi Caietti, Robert Kelly and I had a great conversation. Most of the thread is below.

  • Disband Your PMO

    After nearly 30 years of project work, I struggle to understand the role of a project management office (PMO). Even though, I have written of the pros and cons, and read a plethora of articles, opinions, and how-to guides little has been done to convince me that the PMO is reducing project failure. It seems to be nothing more than a tool to fill a void in leadership? Even the acronym, which is so widely thrown around, has little meaning as the "P" has no less than four meanings. It is an executive's crutch for their lack of understanding in how projects work. These, like other, unattended holes in the corporate accountability create opportunities for new and greater bureaucracies and empires that further obfuscate accountability.

  • Strategic Alignment: The Key To Project Success

    Buy it now!

    Project success rates for many companies and government organizations are dismally low, yet executives never seem to look at the big picture. They continue to make adjustments in the way projects are run by addressing isolated problems. However, projects are part of a much larger system and should be addressed in that context. To do that, companies must define how their strategic plan will use people, projects, and technology to achieve their goals. This paper discusses one approach to make this happen.

  • Challenges In Executive Project Sponsorship

    Buy it now!

    eCameron took a serious look at project sponsorship by conducting a series on non-scientific interviews. Initially the focus was the healthcare industry. As patterns started to emerge, however, others outside of that industry expressed serious interest. To address that interest and better understand the larger issue we expanded the interviews to outside healthcare. Candid and confidential interviews were conducted with project related personnel including executives, sponsors, project managers, and Project Management Office (PMO) managers. In summary:

    • Sponsorship is an issue in all business domains.
    • Good sponsorship is an essential component in creating successful projects.
    • Many issues are pervasive across industries.
    • Sponsors need to work with project managers to design a successful project outcome.
    • Sponsor roles are neither properly defined nor supported.

    This white paper presents the results of the research and highlights areas where organizations need to improve to change their project success rates.

Leave a comment

More Info on Project Recovery

Tell me More!

Please send me more information
on fixing a failing project.

Rescue The Problem Project

Internationally acclaimed

Image of RPP

For a signed and personalized copy in the US visit the our eCommerce website.

Amazon logo
Buy it in the United States Buy it in Canada Buy it in the United Kingdom
Buy it in Ireland Buy it in Germany Buy it in France
Buy it in Italy Buy it in the PRC
Buy it in Japan
Book sellers worldwide.

Upcoming Events

Other's References

Sitemap