Sunday, 23 May 2010 00:00

Finding Gold In Red Projects

Rate this item
(0 votes)

The scope of Rescue the Problem Project

The costs of failing projects are huge. Roger Sessions estimates the cost in the US alone to be $1 trillion annually. The impact, though, goes beyond monetary; it includes reputation, the organization's morale, consumption of resources, and missed opportunity by postponing other projects. Fortunately, there are also many unrealized benefits to glean from troubled projects. To reap those rewards, companies must adopt a culture to exploit failure and learn from it. More often than not, people just want to get the project behind them.

The Environment

The normal process is that a project fails, people are assigned to fix it, they apply corrective actions to the project, and they muscle it to completion. The entire time they vow to fix the root problems as soon as the project is complete. Unfortunately, by the time the project is over, people have been reassigned, management does reluctant to spend more money, and everyone is sure they know the issues and will never repeat them. People are exhausted. The retrospective is forgotten.

Many problems exist in this scenario. To begin with, projects are not self-contained systems; they are a subset of larger systems. They are inside organizations and the people, processes, and policies of those organizations bound the project. To fix the project, one must fix the organization. The solution is to have a company philosophy of addressing problems when they are found.

The Anatomy of Failure

Every recovery is really three projects—the failing project, the recovery project and the newly recovered project. The recovery is sandwiched between to other two projects. The recovery process generates multiple corrective actions to attain the new successful project. The gold in the recovered project is the corrective action. Properly applied corrective action solves the problem so it will not reoccur on this and follow-on projects. To reap that benefit, the problem needs to be fixed at its root cause.

Experience shows that most problems found have little to do with the project itself. The most common problems relate to the organization's policies and people's actions. The problems need to be fixed in the organization, rather than in the project.

For example, one common reason for projects getting in trouble is that the people do not have the correct skills to do the work. There are two commonly proposed solutions to this problem: 1) train team members on the required skills, or 2) replace them with appropriately trained resources. However, this only solves the project's problem. Ask the question, "Why are their skills inadequate?" It is surely not the individual's fault. In many companies, there is a policy that internal people are used prior to bringing in outside resources. This is a great policy and very well intended, if there is also a policy to train people on technologies that are on the corporate roadmap. The training must be part of overhead or factored into the time and cost of the project. Unfortunately, too many organizations reduce the training budget to remain competitive—a fatal mistake.

Analyzing each problem on the project for its root cause will generate a list of organizational changes that will benefit all projects in the future.

Breakaway Companies Embrace Change

As support for the change theory, let us look at a few recently published IBM whitepapers on the attributes of breakaway companies—companies that did not simple prosper, they pulled away from their competition. One cites a number of traits in the corporate culture that made them different from their lesser competitors. They strove to have their management less corrective and more directive; decision support had morphed into action support; operations were taken beyond efficient and were being optimized; and they were no longer using human insight to address problems but rather applied semantics. Companies that were in this class never thought about Band-Aiding problems on projects. It is too slow. Fast organizations fix problems at their source by making agile systems capable of rapid change. They cannot fix problems in the field it is too costly, they need to be fixed at their genesis.

To accomplish this they need to embrace change. IBM research went further and identified the key contributors to success in the breakaway companies. The key was their acceptance of change. Although adherence to procedures was a factor, what really distinguished them were four major contributors:

  • Drive culture and people change management
  • Move to sophisticated data governance systems
  • Implementation of business process change
  • Achieve Organizational alignment

These four items constituted sixty-two percent of the reason they were top performers. Managing the mechanics of the organization was a mere thirty-eight percent of the reason for their success.


To be successful we need to have successful projects. To break the mold of current project failure we need change. Looking beyond reaction and to move to deliberate action is critical to success. This requires drilling into the reasons for failure and solving the problems at their source. It requires a new attitude and culture that realizes that we must change our businesses, remove the organizational barriers, and use each failure to point to new ways of thinking. By doing this, each failure becomes a gold mine showing us what to correct.

Read 9620 times

Related items

  • People vs Process Track Session/Keynote Example

    If you want educational keynote many of our presentations can be keynotes or track sessions. In the example below, the presentation People or Process: Which Impacts Project Success More? is given as a track session.  

    Example People vs Process keynote as a track session

    This session was given at the PMI Sioux Empire Professions Development Day help in Sioux Falls SD on September 9, 2014.

  • Visualizing Change Example

    Visualizing Change presentations have the impact of physicalizing inanimate objects and events. They are fun and involve many of the people in the workshop or presentation. In general, it is easy to get people interested in attending since mentioning that there are rope, chains, whips and blindfolds have a tendency to pique people's interest. But don't worry, as you will see from the video, this is a child-friendly event. The props physicalize constraints, chains of command, slave drivers, ignorance, and the like.

    Many discussions are held ahead of the event to ensure that the correct issues are addressed. This presentation can model nearly any problem or change by helping define the current and future states in a very jocular and interactive manner.

    Visualizing change presentations and workshops cannot be done online.

    Visualizing Change Example
  • What Would You Do? Presentation Example

    The What Would You Do? series of presentations have two goals: 1) educate the audience, and 2) get them involved with developing an answer. They are built on the premise that any audience has a wealth of knowledge and that we need to get away from the talking-head and engage the attendees. The example below is the presentation $305 Million Failure (At the time of this presentation, since it was still in litigation, it was only a $250 Million Failure). There are also ready-made presentations on sponsorship, ethics, and change management. If there is another topic you would like to see, please let us know.

    What Would You Do? example ($305 Million Failure)
  • Vision to Value Track Session/Keynote Example

    If you want educational keynote many of our presentations can be keynotes or track sessions. In the example below, the presentationVision to Value: Executing Strategically Focused Initiatives is given as a track session. This video shows the flexibility to work with the audience in ways that generally cannot be done in keynotes.  

    Example Vision to Value keynote as a track session

    This session was given at the 2014 Instant impact Conference hosted by PMI Olympia on September 5, 2014. It was given twice that day. This is the afternoon session.

  • Extreme Leadership Keynote Example

    Keynotes set the tone for a conference, a day, or give people the ability to pull all of the events from the day together into culminating thought. We offer inspirational, leadership, and technical keynotes. Our flagship keynote is Extreme Leadership and is the example for our keynotes

    Extreme Leadership is a multifaceted keynote fully customizable to your event. It highlights the following aspects of leadership:

    • Leadership is a journey.
    • Leadership is dynamic. You need different approaches to nearly every situation.
    • Leadership does not need authority. It is not a title. It is something you earn.
    • Leaders have positive attitudes regardless of the situation.
    • Leadership does have core technical traits that, as individuals, we can develop. While other traits based on our personalities and are much hard to change.
    • There are leadership passages that we must go through that define who we are as leaders. These may be work-based—a new job, stretch goal assignments, being fried, etc.) or personal (Severe illness, death of a loved one, etc.). These passages are learning events. How we handle them determines what type of leader we become.

    This version of Extreme Leadership is customized for PMI Northern Utah's 750 attendees in the following way:

    • The audience is all project managers
    • The event organizer, Liz Price, had a theme of STEAM (Stories That Enliven and Motivate) she was developing and needed a central message to inspire people on the longest day of their three-day event.
    Extreme Leadership motivational keynote

Leave a comment

Filling Execution Gaps

Available Worldwide

Filling Exectution Gaps cover

Filling Execution Gaps is available worldwide. Below are some options.


PG DirectLogo
Limited Time Price $20.99
Amazon logo
Book or Kindle
Flag of the United States Canadian Flag Flag of the United Kingdom Irish Flag Deutsche Flagge
Drapeau Français Bandiera Italiana PRC flag
Japanese flag
Bandera de España
Flag of India
Bandera de México
Bandeira do Brasil
Flag of Australia
Vlag van Nederland
DeG Press Logo
Barnes and Noble Logo
Books a Million Logo
Booktopia Logo
Worldwide: Many other
book sellers worldwide.

Rescue The Problem Project

Internationally acclaimed

Image of RPP

For a signed and personalized copy in the US visit the our eCommerce website.

Amazon logo
Buy it in the United States Buy it in Canada Buy it in the United Kingdom
Buy it in Ireland Buy it in Germany Buy it in France
Buy it in Italy Buy it in the PRC
Buy it in Japan
Book sellers worldwide.

Upcoming Events

Other's References

More Info on Project Recovery

Tell me More!

Please send me more information
on fixing a failing project.