Sunday, 11 July 2010 00:00

The Revered Decision Maker... Not Really

Rate this item
(0 votes)

The quickest way to get lost, in business or in your personal life, is failing to make decisions. Not knowing where you are headed increases stress and frustration. It would seem natural, then, that teams on projects beleaguered with indecisive management would be excited to have the logjam broken by a dynamic, decisive leader. Simply put, they are not. Every decision has its opponents and they are bound to be irritated, feeling they have lost prestige or stature. However, turning the decision into action requires a unified team. One of the best tools to accomplish this is to understand what impeded decision making and tactfully educating the team members on the source of the problem. This will garner their backing and improve their willingness to support the decision.

Why People Fail To Make Decisions

Indecisive environments frustrate people, their morale sags, and productivity plummets. The problem must be addressed aggressively, with a quality decision process and accountable decision makers. Educating team members on the new process, is the most effective method of gaining their acceptance of decisions coming out of that process. Essential for dissenters, it is also critical to defend the occasional wrong decision.

There are hundreds of reasons for reluctant decision makers. In general, though, they can be grouped into three broad categories—individual, environmental, and situational.

Leader Manager

Does the right things

Does things right

Visionary

Rational

Passionate

Business like

Creative

Persistent

Inspiring Innovation

Tough Minded

Courageous

Analytical Structured

Imaginative

Deliberative

Experimental

Stabilizing

Shares Knowledge

Centralizes Knowledge

Trusting

Guarded

Warm and Radiant

Cool and Reserved

Expresses Humility

Rarely admits to being wrong

Initiator

Implementer

Individual

Some people do not have the fortitude to be decision makers. Making decisions requires taking a stand, defending the decision, and, if it is incorrect, admitting the error and creating the corrective action. People that lack confidence fail to make and defend decisions, while ones that cannot admit an error are trapped in their own pride. It takes confidence, conviction and humility to be a good decision maker.

Of course, there are people that are simply poor decision makers. They do not have the objectivity to gather and analyze the data. They make decisions based on emotion rather that fact, resulting in ill-founded direction.

After identification, handling these situations is easy. Replacing or augmenting the indecisive manager will solve the problem quickly. In these situations, the team rallies behind a new leader—everyone knows where the roadblock has been.

Environmental

Environmental factors, primarily the company culture, are the most difficult to address. Cultures that are fast to blame breed slow decisions. People refuse to make choices until they have foolproof options, plausible deniability, or someone else to blame. Eliminating culpability is a requirement and often escalates all decisions.

Consensus decisions slow organizations and can frustrate many team members. It is nearly impossible to get everyone to agree, it takes significant time and energy. Since no one has ownership or authority to admit there is a problem or make the correction, admission of failure is interminable.

Lack of decision-making authority is the third major group in this category. As opposed to an organization that needs escalation to avoid blame, these organizations do not have the distributed intelligence to make decisions at lower levels. These companies are slow, have trouble surviving in today's business world, and they are rapidly fading from the landscape.

Internal people can rarely correct these problems; they are part of the culture and are blind to the issues. External consultants or new senior management well versed in organization development are the ones that commonly realign the organization to a different methodology.

Situational

Situational problems arise from transient conditions. These are based on localized problems new to the organization. Two examples are lack of problem definition and poor or insufficient data.

There are many times decisions cannot be made because the problem or the desired outcomes are poorly defined. Without understanding either of these, you do not know where you are or where you are headed. Each attempt at making a decision results in identifying too many flaws. The flaws cannot be refuted, since the issues are poorly defined. As the saying goes, "It is like nailing jello to a tree," the decision falls apart before you can take action.

Poor data normally results in bad decisions. Continuing to make bad decisions and failing to realize the source is poor data, conditions indecisiveness. Since almost all decisions are made on estimates, reviewing estimation processes often identifies the source of the problem. Lack of definition, inadequate understanding of the problem, or over confidence regularly lies at the root.

These problems are usually solved by adding people with specialized experience to provide accurate assessments. Internal resources or consultants can help break this logjam by pinpointing the problem and correcting it.

Moving Forward

Decision-making processes are complex. Reading Leadership Decision Making, by Dr. Hossein Arsham, will give you a good overview of its complexity. Understanding this complexity improves decision making.

Read 8917 times

Related items

  • People vs Process Track Session/Keynote Example

    If you want educational keynote many of our presentations can be keynotes or track sessions. In the example below, the presentation People or Process: Which Impacts Project Success More? is given as a track session.  

    Example People vs Process keynote as a track session

    This session was given at the PMI Sioux Empire Professions Development Day help in Sioux Falls SD on September 9, 2014.

  • Webinar Topic Example

    Nearly any topic that Todd Williams writes about or speaks on, he can do a webinar. You can find some of his "uni-directional" webinars on ProjectManagement.com (see partial listing below) or you can have a fully interactive session as in the audio clip.  The limitations of the session are based on the tool used. In this example, the ZOOM meeting tool was used and it did not allow recording of the video. The session was recorded on May 29, 2019 at 12:30PM London time (4:30AM Pacific). There were about a dozen people online, about half of them had their video turned on, and the meeting organizer (Jonathan Norman) moderated the call. 

    What Example Webinar: Eliminating Blame Covers

    Here are three uni-directional webinar examples posted on ProjectManagement.com (these are free to PMI Members)

  • Transform Your Project Leadership: For Professionals Leading Projects or Company Initiatives

    Todd Williams contributed Chapter 7, "Leaders Listen." You can buy it on Amazon.

    More coming soon!

  • Filling Execution Gaps: How Executives and Project Managers Turn Corporate Strategy into Successful Projects
    What Filling Execution Gaps Covers

    Filling Execution Gaps

    by Todd C. Williams
    ISBN: 978-1-5015-0640-6
    De G Press (DeGruyter), September 2017

    Project alignment, executive sponsorship, change management, governance, leadership, and common understanding. These six business issues are topics of daily discussions between executives, middle management, and project managers; they are the pivotal problems plaguing transformational leadership. Any one of these six, when improperly addressed, will hex a project's chances for success. And, they do—daily—destroying the ability companies to turn vision into value.

    Check it out on Amazon or the Filling Execution Gaps website

    Without the foundation of a common understanding of goals and core concepts, such as value being critical to success, communication stops and projects fail.

    Without change management, users fail to adopt project deliverables, value is lost, and projects fail.

    Without maintaining alignment between corporate goals and projects, projects miss their value targets and projects fail.

    Without an engaged executive sponsor, scope increases, goals drift, chaos reigns, value is lost, and projects fail.

    Without enough governance, critical connections are not made, steps are ignored, value is overlooked, and projects fail.

    Too much governance slows progress, companies cannot respond to business pressures, value drowns in bureaucracy, and projects fail.

    Without strong leadership defining the vision and value, goals are not set, essential relationships do not form, teams do not develop, essential decisions are not made, and projects fail.

  • Filling Execution Gaps: Building Success-Focused Organizations

    Executives define vision, strategy, and goals to advance the business. Projects enable companies to meet those goals. Between strategy and projects, there is a lot of work to be done—work that lays the foundation for project and operational success. Through experience and research, six common gaps exist in organizations that inhibit project success—an absence of common understanding, disengaged executive sponsors, misalignment with goals, poor change management, ineffective governance, and lackluster leadership.

Leave a comment

Filling Execution Gaps

Available Worldwide

Filling Exectution Gaps cover

Filling Execution Gaps is available worldwide. Below are some options.

 

PG DirectLogo
Limited Time Price $20.99
Amazon logo
Book or Kindle
Flag of the United States Canadian Flag Flag of the United Kingdom Irish Flag Deutsche Flagge
Drapeau Français Bandiera Italiana PRC flag
Japanese flag
Bandera de España
Flag of India
Bandera de México
Bandeira do Brasil
Flag of Australia
Vlag van Nederland
DeG Press Logo
Barnes and Noble Logo
Books a Million Logo
Booktopia Logo
Worldwide: Many other
book sellers worldwide.

Rescue The Problem Project

Internationally acclaimed

Image of RPP

For a signed and personalized copy in the US visit the our eCommerce website.

Amazon logo
Buy it in the United States Buy it in Canada Buy it in the United Kingdom
Buy it in Ireland Buy it in Germany Buy it in France
Buy it in Italy Buy it in the PRC
Buy it in Japan
Book sellers worldwide.

Upcoming Events

Other's References

More Info on Project Recovery

Tell me More!

Please send me more information
on fixing a failing project.

Sitemap